[R&U] [Autopass] - Klaivesmit​hing and Silver Weapons

Status message

Displaying output for plurality voting

Open Votes

Proposal Type: Bylaw Revision
Opened: 24-Sep-2014 12:00AM EDT
Closing: 24-Sep-2014 12:00AM EDT


This proposal was brought forth with the potential to autopass. If there are no objections during the 7-day discussion period (that started on September 16, 2014), it will autopass.

This proposal autopassed.

------------------------

I, Justin Quigley, propose the following changes to the R&U Bylaws

---

Current:

vi. Klaivesmithing and Grand/Great/Bane Klaives


1. The creation of silver weapons/fetishes by Garou, including but not limited to klaives, in any aspect other than performing the Rite of the Fetish" will be Coordinator Approval.

 2. All Grand, Great, and Bane Klaives, regardless of how they are acquired in game will need Coordinator Approval.


---


Proposed:

vi.  Grand/Great/Bane Klaives

1. All Grand, Great, and Bane Klaives, regardless of how they are acquired in game will need Coordinator Approval.

---

Rationale: I don't feel that a restriction on Garou silversmiths are very necessary. STs can have that control, especially since most STs don't even know that this verbiage is tucked in under the Klaive section to begin with.

Also, it doesn't make a great deal of sense to me for there to be a restriction on making a silver knife but not a Fetished silver knife. This was a knee jerk in reaction to a single PC, and I don't think it's needed any longer.

File / Document: No file attachments for this vote.
Ballot Options